Home | Columnist | Supreme Court Order on Election Tribunal Rulings

Supreme Court Order on Election Tribunal Rulings

By
Font size: Decrease font Enlarge font

Governorship election tribunals in Benue and Akwa Ibom states are to repeat the trial of the petitions against the election of their incumbent governors

The Supreme Court Monday, November 14, 2011, ordered the governorship election petition tribunals sitting in Benue and Akwa Ibom states to retry the cases filed by the Action Congress of Nigeria, ACN, and its candidates in the two states.

The apex court in the two rulings said election petitions should not be dismissed on mere technicalities. The ruling finally put to rest the controversies as to whether pre-hearing notice should be by way of ex-parte or by a mere letter. The issue had polarised the judiciary and the tribunals giving different interpretations.

The Court, of Appeal did not help matters. Different divisions of the court also gave divergent interpretations. Steve Ugbah, ACN’s governorship candidate in Benue State, and John Akpanudoedehe, his Akwa Ibom counterpart, won appeals brought before the Supreme Court, challenging the decision of the Court of Appeal which dismissed their petitions on the grounds that the notices of pre-hearing were not properly filed.

Ugbah is challenging the declaration of Gabriel Suswam as the governor of Benue State on the grounds that his (Suswam) election was fraudulent and marred by irregularities, while Akpanudoedehe on the other hand is challenging the victory of Godswill Akpabio, governor of Akwa Ibom State, alleging electoral irregularities.

The Supreme Court, in a unanimous decision read by Dahiru Musdapher , Chief Justice of Nigeria, CJN, held that the petitions should not have been dismissed on mere technicalities, pointing out that pre-hearing notice could even be done orally. The court stated that the petitions should be heard based on merit, and remitted the petitions back to the tribunals in the states.

Musdapher said the petitions should be determined on their merits and that pre-hearing conference should not be a basis to dismiss petitions. “The justice of the matter is that the appeals be remitted back for hearing on their merits. I don’t know why judges should on the basis of pre-hearing conference alone dismiss a petition without hearing it on its merit. Matters must be decided on their merits,” he said.

He stated further that there was no difference between a letter or ex-parte motion, as he insisted that matters should be decided only on merits, not technicalities. “It is too early for me to start losing my head. What is the difference between a letter or ex-parte motion? Everybody is watching us. I am begging you in the name of justice, matters should be decided on their merits and not technicalities,” Musdapher said.

He maintained that it was the responsibility of the court to handle cases before it based on its merits not technicalities, as he warned that the easy way out of cases should not be condoned by the judiciary. “They just want to take an easy way out to finish the matter.  We will say no to it. Democracy is the number of people who vote for A or B; where is justice after the tribunal itself issued the pre-hearing notice?  The same tribunal has fixed hearing and after some days, somebody now brought an application for the dismissal of the petition, where is the justice in that situation?  Let justice be done,” the CJN said.

 

  • Email to a friend Email to a friend
  • Print version Print version
  • Plain text Plain text

Tagged as:

No tags for this article

Rate this article

0

Breaking News

Indicted Companies, Their Owners

Many highly placed Nigerians who own some of the companies indicted for fuel subsidy offences are likely to be arraigned in court this week The stage ...

Still a Killing Field

Fear and grief take the centre stage again in Jos after another round of crisis leading to the death of more than140 persons including two ...

Battle to Save LGs

A presidential committee headed by retired Justice Alfa Belgore suggests ways to salvage the nation’s local governments from the over bearing influence of state governors The ...

Twist in the Akpabio’s Murder Case

The family of the murdered Akpabio brothers rejects the setting up of a security committee to investigate the multiple murder incident and demands explanation for ...

Akwa Ibom Triumphs

Cross River State loses its bid to reclaim 76 oil wells which it lost through its declassification as a littoral state For Godswill Akpabio, governor of ...

Danger at the Door

Fear of religious war looms as Boko Haram sect targets churches and Christians for attacks T he   ordination   ceremony of Matthew Hassan Kukah as the Catholic ...

Danger at the Door

Fear of religious war looms as Boko Haram sect targets churches and Christians for attacks T he   ordination   ceremony of Matthew Hassan Kukah as the Catholic ...

Christians Have a Right to Defend Themselves

Gabriel Osu, monsignor and director of communications, Catholic Archdiocese of Lagos, speaks to Anthony Akaeze, assistant editor, on a number of issues relating to the ...

It’s Not a War Against Christians

Lateef Adegbite, secretary general, Supreme Council for Islamic Affairs, speaks to Dike Onwuamaeze, principal staff writer, and Ishaya Ibrahim, staff writer, on Boko Haram. Excerpts: Newswatch: ...

On the Rise Again

Cases of kidnapping are again on the increase in Imo State There is an upsurge in kidnapping in Imo State. The cases are much more than ...